First of all, I didn’t proofread this entry, and I’m not going to, so there!
A week or so ago, my buddy Kyle and I agreed to send each other a mix disc and then write a blog on the specific songs on each other’s disc. Kyle sent me a mix disc with a bunch of his favorite artists on it, and I sent him a mix of Hey Rosetta! songs—you know, that band I won’t shut up about and which the most attractive woman I’ve ever dated says makes me a “hipster” (I’m just playing around Kiwi, my feelings weren’t hurt).
Kyle wrote his blog about the Hey Rosetta disc yesterday, and you can read that here. I implore you to read it; Kyle is a very entertaining blogger, and I hear he’s hilarious when he takes Ritalin rectally.
So anyway, I’ll now review what I thought of the songs on Kyle’s mix disc, track-for-track, and I shall pull no punches. I may savage a few of these, but at the same time, please know that anything I say I liked, I quite genuinely did. First off, I’ll just show you the track listing:
1. Elton John, “Funeral For a Friend/ Love Lies Bleeding”
2. Stevie Wonder, “All Day Sucker”
3. X Posed, “Point of No Return”
4. Parliament, “Night of the Thumpasaurus People”
5. Lady Gaga, “Speechless”
6. Tom Waits, “Falling Down”
7. Stevie Wonder, “Blame it on the Sun”
8. Meat Loaf, “You Took the Words Right Out of my Mouth”
9. Elton John, “Roy Rogers”
10. My Brightest Diamond, “From the Top of the World”
1. Elton John, “Funeral For a Friend/ Love Lies Bleeding”
So this is one of those 2 song dealies where one bleeds into the other and they are both one track (but not like a suite–they are clearly seperate songs) and boy howdy, Kyle picked a great way to open this disc! “Funeral”, especially, is very much my type of music. It’s instrumental, and very much a combination of rock and classical music, and very foreboding and dark and ominous. This is very close to the sub-genre of rock I like very much, Post Rock. I did not know Mr. John had anything like this. I love it, but I doubt there’s more of it. “Love Lies Bleeding” I found to be an above-average Elton John song but it lacks enough drama or cajones to be following on the heels of “Funeral for a Friend”. Although, it has given me a deeper appreciation of the Fuel song “Hemorrhage (in My Hands)”, which I like very much and I now see directly references this song. (sidenote: Fuel are noted Elton John fans. Never heard their cover of “Daniel”? Please do.)
2. Stevie Wonder, “All Day Sucker”
OK people, listen here, this song rules. And I was not prepared for that. I’ve never even thought for a split second about paying any attention to Stevie Wonder. Now, I must say, the reason I like this as much as I do is because it is very close to being a “rock” song. It’s got crunchy guitars and a rock-and-roll growl to it, as well as a certain swagger in the lyrics. It is, at the very least, rock-centric funk, and I like it’s balls. Listen to the 30 second preview of the song here.
3. X posed, “Point of No Return”
This is actually a pretty famous 80s tune. It’s one of those songs that gets in your head and is really catchy and fun, but definitely not my thing. I’d say what it lacks, for me, is any even minor attempt at lyrical substance. I know this is a point where Kyle and I’s tastes begins to differ, but if there are words in a song, I want at least a little meat on them. It can even be, like, buffalo wings amount of meat (for instance, I still like The Bloodhound Gang) but there’s gotta be more than a few phrases thrown around for repetition’s sake. If you don’t have anything to say, make an instrumental! And good God, it is at least a full minute too long!
4. Parliament, “Night of the Thumpasaurus People”
Now this is good shit. While I’m no total stranger to Parliament (when I was a young man I once bought George Clinton’s solo album Smell My Finger and used the songs off that album as the soundtrack to my now legendary film “Kiteman”. Since then I’ve always been quite curious about what came before that in Clinton’s career), I must say I was a total newbie to this song, and I love it!!!! It is classic dirty, swinging funk with almost no words, but the chanted nonsense refrain will worm it’s way into your brain and lodge itself in there until you hit the “repeat” button on your stereo. If you are a person who is alive you will want to watch this YouTube video.
5. Lady Gaga, “Speechless”
I quite honestly continue to have no idea what to think about Lady Gaga. Once performers begin referencing culture, and the fame they themselves attain, and start doing things like spectacle for specatacle’s sake or dressing funny, I frankly have no idea what’s going on. Is the music good or do we just think it’s good? Is this person interestng or do we just think they’re interesting (and that, in turn, makes them interesting)? Does it matter that she wore something bizarre (and if it didn’t matter, why’d she do it?)? I am not bothered by any of this, and do not “hate” on her like many others do, but I sort of throw my hands up about it because it hurts my head and I don’t really care about it all. Every song I’ve heard of hers isn’t bad at all, but it doesn’t knock my socks off either. This song, “Speechless”, is an OK song, but I can’t say as I can hear it my head right now, either. Her image and what she’s trying to do, culturally, naturally remind us all of early Madonna, but I’m not hearing a “Like a Virgin” or “Like a Prayer” sort of scorcher coming from Gaga. “Speechless” needs something like a tempo change or big, classic hook to shoot it into the rarefied air she seems to be reaching for.
6. Tom Waits, “Falling Down”
I already have Kyle to thank for introducing me to Tom Waits in the first place and he’s quickly becoming one of my favorite artists. And “Falling Down” is one of my new favorites. Haunting, visceral, yet plain and straight-forward, this is the sort of song that can compliment any mood while also turning that mood into a mini-cry fest. (I’m not gay)
7. Stevie Wonder, “Blame it On the Sun”
I wasn’t as thrilled with this one as I was with the other Stevie song, but I do dig the lyrics and the arrangement; it was just a tad sleepy for me. I think if kept at the same tempo but added an acoustic guitar to the mix, I’d be much happier (what IS that stringed instrument that’s in ther already? A harp?)
8. Meat Loaf, “You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth”
Sorry dude. I just really don’t like Meat Loaf, and this song is no exception. His songs are jokes that think they’re serious, and trifles that think they’re epics. I mean, the lyrics to this song–which you can tell Mr. Loaf takes quite seriously–read like the poem of an 8th grade girl. Sure, there’s a couple neat tricks, but nothing that qualifies for inclusion in the canon with great songwriters. And then this cutesy line about her taking the words out of his mouth “while you were kissing me”—I mean what is this, Motown? Is this a song by The Platters? And you can tell he thinks it’s clever because he sings it 35 times. I call shenanigans. And musically it just sounds like another Meat Loaf tune. (sorry dude, I told you I hate Meat Loaf!)
9. Elton John, “Roy Rogers”
Now here is a great song!!! Just good, classic, mid-tempo thoughtful and intelligent rock. It’s getting better the more I hear it and I think I may end up claiming it as one of my favorite songs if I keep liking it this much more very day. Thank you Kyle for introducing me to it!!! I’d say more but it’s kinda amazing. Read the lyrics here and hear it here. You will not regret doing these things!
10. My Brightest Diamond, “From the Top of the World”
This is a great song and I suspect this band is great, too. I’m almost ashamed I didn’t already know about them. Right down my alley. It’s got that dark, Indie-rock sound I’ve found so favorable in bands like The Walkmen, Islands, The National, among others, except My Brightest Diamond boasts a female vocalist, which is rare in this particular sub-genre and which I like very much. Watch the official video. I’ll definitely be looking more into them Kyle! Thanks for introducing me to them as well as quite a few other great things on this disc, as well as cementing my belief that Meat Loaf is a total fucking hack! Until next time everyone, peace in the Middle East!